transcript
Speaker 1:
[00:00] Hi, I'm Wendy Zukerman, and you're listening to Science Vs. This is the show that pits facts against phones. Today on the show, how do we stop scrolling? Just last week in a landmark case, Meta, which owns Instagram and Google, owner of YouTube, were found negligent for basically creating addictive products that harmed a young woman's mental health.
Speaker 2:
[00:31] A huge slap to big tech today.
Speaker 3:
[00:34] A landmark verdict that could change the face of social media.
Speaker 4:
[00:37] Deliberately and negligently designed their products to get young users hooked on the apps.
Speaker 5:
[00:42] They kept her endless scrolling, constant notifications, algorithms that learn exactly what keeps you watching.
Speaker 1:
[00:50] The tech giants have been ordered to pay her $6 million. They're appealing. But this case has reignited a huge conversation over how these apps can just suck us in. The young woman's lawyer said during closing arguments that these apps are, quote, Trojan horses. They look wonderful and great, but you invite them in and they take over. Which, away from this case, is exactly the way that a lot of our listeners have been feeling about these apps.
Speaker 6:
[01:23] I want to use my phone less, obviously, like everyone else.
Speaker 7:
[01:26] I've been trying to quit for the last two years.
Speaker 8:
[01:29] It has gotten worse.
Speaker 9:
[01:31] I want to stop doing scrolling. It just feels like I'm constantly consuming something off of a screen.
Speaker 1:
[01:37] Surveys find that over half of adults in the US want to spend less time on their phones.
Speaker 9:
[01:43] My mental health is just better when I'm off social media and it's hard to get out of the scrolling.
Speaker 1:
[01:49] So, the question we have for this episode is this. Given that so many of us feel hooked, is there any way to unhook ourselves, to stop scrolling? Rather ironically, online, you can find tons of people claiming that they've found the answer.
Speaker 10:
[02:07] These are five really simple brain tricks that can help you break social media addiction and stop doom scrolling.
Speaker 3:
[02:12] The first tip is friction stacking.
Speaker 11:
[02:14] We need to create as many layers between us and that damn phone.
Speaker 12:
[02:17] If you can slay that dragon, if you can resist temptation, well, you can do anything.
Speaker 1:
[02:26] So how do you slay that dragon? Is there anything that can actually get us off our phones? That's science approved.
Speaker 5:
[02:35] When it comes to scrolling, a lot of us have been endless scrolling, constant notifications, and then there's science.
Speaker 1:
[02:45] Science Vs. Scrolling, we'll be right back just after the break. Don't look at your phone.
Speaker 10:
[02:58] This episode is brought to you by Claude from Anthropic. Some of the greatest innovations came from someone just wanting to help. The scientists who founded Anthropic wanted to build AI that's safe and benefits humanity, and Claude is where that research comes to life. Claude doesn't just hand you quick answers, it thinks with you, digging into complexity, finding contradictions, and helping you work through the nuance, which, if you listen to this show, you know is where the real science lives. See why problem solvers choose Claude as their thinking partner at claude.ai. Science Vs.
Speaker 13:
[03:30] Protein is now at Starbucks, and it's never tasted so good. You can add protein cold foam to your favorite drink or try one of our new protein lattes or matcha. Try it today at Starbucks.
Speaker 1:
[03:49] Welcome back. There's a lot of chat right now about how these tech giants have created social media apps designed to suck us in. Now we're going to talk about how to get unsucked. Time for the science with Meryl Horn, Senior Producer. Hello.
Speaker 14:
[04:06] Hi, Wendy.
Speaker 5:
[04:07] It's been a while since we've been chatting about science.
Speaker 14:
[04:11] Yeah, it has.
Speaker 1:
[04:12] So have you been spending all that time on your phone?
Speaker 14:
[04:19] Sometimes it feels like that.
Speaker 1:
[04:21] Seriously, do you have a problem with scrolling?
Speaker 14:
[04:24] Do you think? Yeah. The reason I wanted to do this episode was because I'd find myself just staring at my phone for way longer than I meant to, especially at the end of the day. And it wouldn't even feel like good. I would often feel worse about my life or just crappy in general and yet I'd spend all this time scrolling, scrolling, scrolling.
Speaker 1:
[04:51] Yeah. And this is a feeling that many of us have had. And it's kind of crazy to think about how pervasive this feeling is. So Meryl, when it comes to this question of how do we stop scrolling, I mean, where do we begin?
Speaker 14:
[05:09] Well first off, the research does find that scrolling itself is especially bad compared to other things we do on our phones. So like one study asked people like how they felt after doing different things on their phones and the researchers could spy on them to see like exactly what they were using their phones for. And they found that yeah, it was like the scrolling that people said they regretted the most compared to stuff like communicating with their friends or like getting information. You could also see this in how much they regretted going on certain apps. Like after they went on Instagram, they would say that I regretted that like 42% of the time where when they went on a messaging app, they only regretted it 18% of the time. And another study backed this up finding something really similar, but this one looked at meaninglessness instead, which you know again found that people said their experience was more meaningless if they had just spent that time scrolling compared to this other stuff, which helped me understand like why it feels so bad.
Speaker 1:
[06:14] But then why do we keep doing it, do you think?
Speaker 14:
[06:17] Because it's like it does give us some kind of like short-term happiness a lot of the time to scroll. The whole reason we do it is because we're probably getting some kind of you know dopamine hits, or you know those the parts of our brain that light up when we're doing something. Rewarding, or do light up when we like see social media.
Speaker 1:
[06:33] Okay, okay, so that I mean that is why yeah we keep going back for more. So then we know what happens next, how do we stop? And you know I don't want to completely put the onus on us to work out how to unsuck ourselves from social media. The big tech companies clearly have a role to play here. But while we're waiting for them to sort it out, Beryl, do you have anything that we can do for ourselves?
Speaker 14:
[07:05] I do, yes. So let's dive in and find out what actually works here to stop scrolling. So to start, let's meet Jaejeung Kim. He's an assistant professor at Cheongnam National University in Korea. He's also had a problem with scrolling. For him, YouTube is the thing that would get him.
Speaker 3:
[07:23] I kept on watching, watching, and I end up watching something that I never intended.
Speaker 14:
[07:29] You just get sucked down these rabbit holes.
Speaker 3:
[07:31] Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 1:
[07:32] Scientists and people too.
Speaker 14:
[07:34] Yeah, but he has done a lot of work trying to figure out exactly what strategies work to stop. Like how can people break these habits?
Speaker 1:
[07:43] Yeah.
Speaker 14:
[07:44] And so I wanted to start with the most hardcore intervention that he's come up with. Do you want to guess what they did to help people stop scrolling?
Speaker 1:
[07:54] Delete the apps. Put your phone in the bin. By a Nokia from the early 2000s.
Speaker 14:
[08:01] Nice guesses. I guess it wasn't that extreme a way.
Speaker 5:
[08:10] None of these are crazy.
Speaker 14:
[08:12] Well, not too many people would sign up for a study, I don't think, where they had to get rid of their phones.
Speaker 1:
[08:19] I would, Jaejeung, if you want to go even more extreme, I'll sign up. Okay, so what did they do?
Speaker 14:
[08:26] So his approach was to just make an app that would kick you off your phone. If you go past a certain time limit, then you couldn't use your phone for anything, except to make phone calls.
Speaker 6:
[08:37] Okay.
Speaker 14:
[08:39] So yeah, first, you know, there's about 40 people, and first you had to put in your goals for how long you want to spend on your phone. So like, maybe you're using it for five hours a day and you want to go down to four hours a day. Then you got this special app. It's called Goalkeeper, and it had three different levels. So sometimes people would just get the easy levels, basically a control where you just get a warning message when you go past your time limit. And another one, you just get kicked off your phone for a little bit of time. But then the third level is the intense one. So Jaejeung called this condition, strong lockout.
Speaker 3:
[09:16] And the strong lockout is what I was very interested in. I was… I'm eager to lock people out.
Speaker 14:
[09:22] Just because you want to make people suffer?
Speaker 3:
[09:25] Yeah, I want to… I want to see the greatest effect. So we locked them out until the midnight. After the time exceeded.
Speaker 1:
[09:38] It's interesting that he said it'll come back on at midnight. Like Cinderella. Because that would be the worst time to then get access to your phone.
Speaker 5:
[09:47] It's going to interrupt with your sleep.
Speaker 1:
[09:49] At least just keep it off until 8am or something.
Speaker 14:
[09:53] That's true. But then people will be eating up their time for the next day. So yeah, people were very aware of how much time they had left on their phone.
Speaker 1:
[10:02] Okay.
Speaker 14:
[10:03] And so everyone tried out these kind of different levels of the app for one week. And I first wanted to know, yeah, what happened when people were in the week when they had the really hardcore approach, the strong lockout. First, let's just look at, did it work to get people to use their phones less?
Speaker 3:
[10:20] Yes, it did. Yes, it did. It's quite effective.
Speaker 14:
[10:23] So yeah, people did use their phones for roughly 75 minutes less every day. So in that sense, it works.
Speaker 1:
[10:31] Yeah.
Speaker 14:
[10:31] But then the caveat was that people really didn't like it. At least a lot of the time, they said they felt more frustrated and coerced compared to the control condition where they were just getting a little warning, but they didn't actually get locked out of their phone. Then they got really stressed out when they saw that the time was getting close to when they would have to get cut off.
Speaker 1:
[10:53] Yes, that's the point.
Speaker 14:
[10:55] Yeah, but I think the thing that was frustrating was that we use our phones for a lot of different things, right?
Speaker 1:
[11:01] Yes, of course, yes.
Speaker 14:
[11:02] So when we get locked out of everything altogether, it can be really annoying.
Speaker 1:
[11:06] Yes, it's a big stick. It's a big stick, that's right. And there can be days where you're off Instagram, but you've got a lot of work stuff to do, blah, blah, blah. You're traveling, you want to listen to a bunch of podcasts, and then you've...
Speaker 14:
[11:18] You just want to pay for the subway. I do all the sorts of things with my phone. I don't want to be locked out altogether. And then there's one other super kind of hardcore study I wanted to tell you about, since you were interested in, you know, signing up for a study yourself, where you just have to like get rid of your phone. So I talked to this researcher who set up this study where they wanted to cut the internet off people's phones for two weeks, but then when it was actually time to start the experiment and download this app that cut off the internet, a ton of people didn't actually go through with it. So more than 40% of them just didn't even get the app, even though they signed up for the study. And then even a bunch of people who got the app kept cheating. They like re-enabled the internet again and again and again during the study. So even though you think you might want something super extreme, it seems like for a lot of people, they don't actually want to do this.
Speaker 15:
[12:14] Okay. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker 1:
[12:16] Yeah, I could see myself falling on my own petard or whatever that phrase is.
Speaker 14:
[12:25] Petard? Petard?
Speaker 16:
[12:27] Petard?
Speaker 1:
[12:28] I don't know. I'm just saying words.
Speaker 14:
[12:30] I guess that's a loaf of bread. So maybe we should go in the opposite direction. What if all we need to do to stop scrolling is a little reminder, like a gentle nudge, something that dad just asks us, like, are you sure you want to be doing this right now? So Jaejeung has also tried this approach. In a different study, he created an app where people would just get a little pop-up window when they tried to open up certain apps and they could just get rid of this little pop-up with a little click of the button.
Speaker 1:
[13:04] Yes, quite a few people have apps similar to this.
Speaker 14:
[13:08] Yeah, I've tried this out before because the iPhone comes with like a screen time app that works similar to this.
Speaker 1:
[13:14] Oh yeah, I have always wondered, does it actually work? Because the pop-up comes on and it's quite a low hurdle to just say, yeah, this is what I want to do.
Speaker 14:
[13:23] Yeah, it's easy to hit ignore, but it does give you that little nudge, right?
Speaker 1:
[13:27] Yeah, that's right.
Speaker 14:
[13:28] And so yeah, he, Jaejeung set up the study where first people had to put in a list of apps that they wanted to like stop themselves from going on to so much.
Speaker 3:
[13:38] So we call it like the blacklist app. So it could be like, you know, Facebook, Instagram or YouTube.
Speaker 14:
[13:46] And then he looked at what happened when people got this little pop-up window. Did they decide not to go on to those blacklisted apps?
Speaker 3:
[13:54] It has reduced the use about 10% to 15%.
Speaker 14:
[14:00] Just from getting that little box that just says, do you want to continue? Yes or no?
Speaker 3:
[14:04] Yes. Yes. Yes. And that little stop have made you think and reconsider your use.
Speaker 1:
[14:13] So what have similar studies found? Does this gentle nudging work generally? We've got Jaejeung's study.
Speaker 14:
[14:19] Yeah. Other studies do find that it can work a little bit like Jaejeung's. But then a bunch of other studies didn't find any effects. So, yeah, I found a review that kind of looked at all these studies together. And bottom line, it called this type of strategy, quote, barely effective.
Speaker 5:
[14:39] OK.
Speaker 1:
[14:41] OK. It's just too easy to swat that fly away.
Speaker 5:
[14:45] You sure? You sure? Yeah, I'm sure.
Speaker 1:
[14:47] I want to stay on the app.
Speaker 14:
[14:49] I just automatically ignore it every single time. So for me, it wasn't surprising that it doesn't work great.
Speaker 1:
[14:55] OK.
Speaker 14:
[14:56] So I think, yeah, we probably we need to turn up the dial, back up a little bit now, right? Because, you know, maybe the problem with these kind of approaches, the gentle nudge, is that there's not enough, like, friction. So I don't know if you've heard of this. There's like a buzzword online right now. Influencers are like, you know, to stop scrolling, you need to up the friction.
Speaker 1:
[15:17] Right.
Speaker 5:
[15:17] So the friction is too hot, and the friction is too cold.
Speaker 1:
[15:20] We need the goldilocks about of friction to stop us from scrolling.
Speaker 14:
[15:25] And, you know, some of our listeners mentioned this sort of approach, like making it harder to use their apps, as, like, having worked for some of them.
Speaker 6:
[15:34] Now what I've tried, and to pretty good success, is hide all the social media apps on your phone. That has really helped.
Speaker 9:
[15:41] I haven't found, like, a bullet solution, but the Brick app has really helped me.
Speaker 14:
[15:47] The Brick is something, it's, I've been getting ads for it a ton. It's, like, this little device that, like, you physically have to, like, go to to unlock your apps. That's sort of expensive. There's also cheaper ways to do the same thing. There's one called Touch Grass, where you have to, like, go outside and, like, take a picture of yourself touching grass before you can use your apps. So this is, it's a really common strategy. But let's find out if it actually, like, what actually happens when people try this. So in that study that Jaejeung did, where, you know, people put in these blacklisted apps, in other cases, they, he made it harder for them to get to those apps. They couldn't just, you know, click it away. People would get a pop-up window where you had to enter in a string of numbers before you could go on to the app. So sometimes it was only ten digits long. Other times, it was a 30-digit long number that they had to like manually put in before they got to use their app. I asked Jaejeung what this was like.
Speaker 3:
[16:46] Very frustrating. And our participant mentioned that, oh, there's one little thing. Once you failed to input 30-digit number at once, you have to retype it.
Speaker 14:
[16:59] You have to start all over again.
Speaker 12:
[17:00] Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 3:
[17:03] Yeah. So it's very frustrating.
Speaker 1:
[17:06] Yeah. I was imagining that's what would happen. Very frustrating. Very frustrating. Okay. So surely that stops you going on the app, right? That feels like enough.
Speaker 14:
[17:18] Yeah. Yeah. So in the study, again, around 40 people, a few weeks long, he looked at like what happened when they got these different kind of levels. And yeah, especially when they got the 30-digit number, a lot of the time they decided, I'm not even going to bother.
Speaker 1:
[17:33] Yeah.
Speaker 14:
[17:33] Almost half the time, they decided like, yeah, F this. It's not worth it to go on this app. And the other, the 10-digit number like worked okay too. So overall, it did work to get people to stop going on their apps as much. But there is a pretty big caveat to this.
Speaker 15:
[17:53] Okay.
Speaker 14:
[17:54] Which is that once people were in the app, they then spent more time in it than they would have done otherwise.
Speaker 15:
[18:01] Oh.
Speaker 1:
[18:06] You know what this is like, Meryl?
Speaker 14:
[18:07] What?
Speaker 1:
[18:08] It's like when people are waiting in line at an ice cream shop. And then when they get to the front, they have to get all the friggin tasters.
Speaker 14:
[18:18] To take their time, yeah.
Speaker 1:
[18:20] Exactly, exactly.
Speaker 5:
[18:22] But we're still waiting in the line.
Speaker 7:
[18:25] Heather?
Speaker 14:
[18:28] Yeah, it's exactly like that.
Speaker 1:
[18:29] Is this what happened? Yeah, okay.
Speaker 14:
[18:32] Yeah, here's Jaejeung.
Speaker 3:
[18:33] So once they got in, so, hey, once I got in, I want to use this for 30 minutes instead of like 10 minutes, 10 minutes, 10 minutes, 3 times of 10 minutes sessions. So the frequency decreased, but the total time remained the same.
Speaker 14:
[18:48] So overall, people didn't actually spend less time on their blacklisted apps. So like, I mean, maybe this is still helpful. If your goal is to go on to your apps less often, to like kind of do that checking, checking, like habitual checking less. But if your goal is to spend less time on your phone, it might not work to do this kind of friction approach. And then one final thing from the study I thought was interesting, they looked at what people did when they did decide to not go on to that naughty listed app. And it turns out about half the time people just went to some other app instead. So they were still on their phones often just doing something else that maybe they thought was better for them because they didn't put it on their blacklist.
Speaker 10:
[19:32] Okay.
Speaker 1:
[19:33] Yeah. Yeah, that feels right. I mean, if you're sitting on the toilet, you got to look at something.
Speaker 14:
[19:39] You got to do something.
Speaker 1:
[19:41] All right. So here is what we have learned thus far. If you want to stop scrolling, adding some friction is a good idea. But if the hurdle is too low, like a little pop up, it's not going to work. If the hurdle is too high, once you jump it, watch out, because then you might be spending more time scrolling because you're so proud of yourself for putting in those 30 digits.
Speaker 14:
[20:11] Yeah, that might sort of backfire once you get in.
Speaker 1:
[20:13] So is there any Goldilocks amount of friction then?
Speaker 14:
[20:18] Well, there is actually an approach that nothing to do with friction at all that I found that it seems to be the best way to stop scrolling, according to the science that I found. So I'll tell you what that is after the break.
Speaker 17:
[20:42] Snoring, gasping during sleep, feeling fatigued? Wake up to ZepBound Terzepatide, the first and only FDA-approved prescription medicine for moderate to severe obstructive sleep apnea, OSA, and adults with obesity. ZepBound is an injectable prescription medicine that may help adults with moderate to severe obstructive sleep apnea, OSA, and obesity to improve their OSA. ZepBound should be used with a reduced calorie diet and increased physical activity. ZepBound is approved as a 2.5, 5, 7.5, 10, 12.5, or 15-milligram injection. ZepBound contains terzepotite and should not be used with other terzepotite-containing products or any GLP-1 receptor agonist medicines. It is not known if ZepBound is safe and effective for use in children. Do not share needles or pens, or reuse needles. Don't take ZepBound if allergic to it, or if you or someone in your family had medullary thyroid cancer or multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2. Tell your doctor if you get a lump or swelling in your neck. Stop ZepBound and call your doctor if you have severe stomach pain or a serious allergic reaction. Severe side effects may include inflamed pancreas or gall bladder problems. Tell your doctor if you experience vision changes, depression, or suicidal thoughts before scheduled procedures with anesthesia, if you're nursing, pregnant, planned to be, or taking birth control pills. Taking ZepBound with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. Side effects include nausea, diarrhea, and vomiting, which can cause dehydration and worsen kidney problems. Talk to your doctor. Call 1-800-545-5979 or visit zepbound.lily.com. ZepBound and its delivery device base and quick pin are registered trademarks owned or licensed by Eli Lilly and Company. It's subsidiaries or affiliates.
Speaker 18:
[22:12] Spring is starting at the Home Depot, and we're bringing you low prices guaranteed, so you can wake up your yard this season. Shape up your lawn with top brand outdoor power tools like this Ryobi 40-volt mower with up to 50 minutes of run time. Bring in a splash of color with spring blooms and fresh plants from the Home Depot Garden Center. Then refresh your garden beds and keep them clear weeds with Bigoro mulch free bags for $10. Start your spring with low prices guaranteed only at the Home Depot. Exclusions apply to homedepot.com/pricematch for details.
Speaker 8:
[22:42] K-pop demon hunters Saja Boy's breakfast meal and Huntrix meal have just dropped at McDonald's. They're calling this a battle for the fans. What do you say to that, Rumi?
Speaker 7:
[22:51] It's not a battle. So glad the Saja Boys could take breakfast and give our meal the rest of the day.
Speaker 18:
[22:57] It is an honor to share.
Speaker 10:
[22:58] No, it's our honor.
Speaker 18:
[23:00] It is our larger honor.
Speaker 16:
[23:02] No, really, stop.
Speaker 8:
[23:04] You can really feel the respect in this battle. Pick a meal to pick a side.
Speaker 18:
[23:09] Ba-da-ba-ba-ba.
Speaker 13:
[23:11] And participate in McDonald's while supplies last.
Speaker 19:
[23:13] We all have that dream trip we've been wishing we could go on. But too often, life, or usually price, gets in the way. That's why Priceline is here to help you turn your dream trip into reality. With up to 60% off hotels and up to 50% off flights, you can book everything you need for your next adventure. Don't just dream about that next trip. Book it with Priceline. Download the Priceline app or visit priceline.com and book your next trip today.
Speaker 9:
[23:40] Go to your happy price, Priceline.
Speaker 1:
[23:46] Welcome back. Today, we are talking about how we can stop scrolling. Meryl Horn, Senior Producer at Science Vs. has been looking into this, and I think you've promised us a solution to our scrolling dilemmas.
Speaker 2:
[24:00] Yeah.
Speaker 1:
[24:02] Am I overselling?
Speaker 14:
[24:03] I think, no, I think it's a solution. That's definitely worth trying. It is something that is even easier than a lot of the things we've been talking about to try.
Speaker 1:
[24:13] Let's jump in.
Speaker 14:
[24:14] So next, we're going to meet Dr. Lea-Christin Wickard. She did a study on this. She's a researcher at the University of Copeland in Germany. Basically, all the researchers that I talked to about this, Lea also got into this for personal reasons. She's a psychologist.
Speaker 16:
[24:32] In psychology, we don't do research. We do a me-search.
Speaker 15:
[24:37] Oh, yes.
Speaker 14:
[24:38] Me-search.
Speaker 16:
[24:40] As you can imagine, I have a problem with my phone on my own. So I realized, especially during COVID, that this is a research topic that could really help me with my usage pattern, using my phone, using social media in a healthy and beneficial way, and not only do scroll the whole day.
Speaker 1:
[25:01] What has she uncovered?
Speaker 14:
[25:04] Well, so the idea for her came up in a meeting she was having one day with some students where they're basically brainstorming ways to stop scrolling.
Speaker 16:
[25:12] One of the students talked about, okay, but have a look at our old phones, like the first phones we ever had. It was like in Europe we had this old Nokia phones. It was a black and white phone. We used it to text somebody. We used it to call somebody, maybe play a game, but that's it. And then we discuss, okay, like how can we arrange that nowadays?
Speaker 14:
[25:38] Can we make our phones crappier like they used to be?
Speaker 16:
[25:41] Not to make it more crappy, but to make it less attractive. And we realized all those saturated colors, your blinking red push or notification button, all of those colors keep you distracted and keep you on your phone.
Speaker 14:
[25:59] So yeah, the colors. We know from studies that people generally prefer bright colors. It's probably why our apps are all rainbow colored. And so the idea was maybe if we get rid of these bright colors, make our phones black and white or put it in grayscale, we'll use our phones less. Have you heard of this approach, Wendy?
Speaker 1:
[26:20] I guess I know some people, obviously, who have their phone on grayscale, but I didn't know that this was a tactic to get them to stop using their phones so much.
Speaker 14:
[26:29] Yeah. So do you want to try it, Wendy?
Speaker 1:
[26:31] Sure. Sure, sure, sure. All right.
Speaker 14:
[26:33] And if listeners want to try this too. So on both iPhones and Androids is under accessibility. So Wendy, you have an iPhone?
Speaker 1:
[26:40] Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker 14:
[26:42] Okay. So go to Settings.
Speaker 1:
[26:43] Accessibility.
Speaker 14:
[26:45] Accessibility and then scroll down to Display and Text Size.
Speaker 11:
[26:49] Got it.
Speaker 14:
[26:51] And now Color Filters.
Speaker 1:
[26:52] Yes.
Speaker 14:
[26:53] And toggle that button on. And there you go.
Speaker 1:
[26:56] Okay. Grayscale, here we go. Oh, okay. It's subtle. It's noir. It's classy.
Speaker 14:
[27:07] Well, for me, it was more of a like, whoa, it's like a completely different thing. Like, I felt like it was super dramatic. Did you really?
Speaker 7:
[27:14] I did.
Speaker 14:
[27:15] Yeah, nobody first did it. I was like, what?
Speaker 5:
[27:19] But tell me about the science here.
Speaker 1:
[27:21] So does it actually work? I would be really surprised if this made a difference.
Speaker 14:
[27:27] Well, yeah, let's see what happened in her studies. So she got about 100 people to do this, switch their phones to Grayscale. And yeah, right away, they got a pretty big response.
Speaker 16:
[27:39] We asked our participants, okay, how do you feel? How are you? And what they did say was, it sucks. It's boring. We don't want it. Yeah. Because we want to have our little funny phones. We want to have, we want to play with our phone. We want to have a good time. We want to feel good using our phone. Yeah. But what they also said is, oh, it's really working. Yeah.
Speaker 14:
[28:08] So this generally works. In Lea's study, they found that after a day or two of their phones being on gray scale, people spent a lot less time on their phones over an hour or less on average.
Speaker 1:
[28:20] Whoa, an hour less just because their phone was on gray scale?
Speaker 14:
[28:26] And other, so there's also longer term studies that have people do this for a week that don't find as big effects. So maybe 20 to 40 minutes less a day, like once you get used to it.
Speaker 1:
[28:35] Yeah, right.
Speaker 14:
[28:36] But out of all the four studies that I could find on this, it did work. People use their phones for less time. Yeah, and there's a couple studies that looked at people who are really heavy phone users. They were considered to have problematic smartphone use, which is sort of a hand wavy way of measuring how addicted someone is to their smartphone.
Speaker 1:
[28:56] Okay.
Speaker 14:
[28:56] And they found that gray scale was helpful for them. One study found that people with this felt less anxious after switching their phones to gray scale.
Speaker 1:
[29:05] Oh, I mean, you don't see pokey's machines or what do you call them in the US? Slot machines. You don't see slot machines that are gray scale, right?
Speaker 14:
[29:15] Yeah. And well, but there are some things that are harder to do. I noticed when I put my phone in gray scale, like when someone's calling you the buttons for answering the phone or declining it are in red and green. So now when I'm picking up a call, I'm like, oh gosh, like which button do I push? Like you really have to pay attention to make sure you hit the right one.
Speaker 1:
[29:37] What do you mean? It's that, Meryl.
Speaker 14:
[29:39] You don't realize how dependent you are on the colors until they're gone.
Speaker 1:
[29:44] Okay. All right.
Speaker 14:
[29:45] But for most things it still works okay.
Speaker 1:
[29:47] All right.
Speaker 14:
[29:47] And you know, a few of our listeners told us that this worked for them, including this one whose voice you might recognize.
Speaker 2:
[29:55] I have been using gray scale for like three weeks. And then when I look at my screen time report, my screen time is down, my phone time is down like 30 percent, which is actually more than I thought it would be.
Speaker 15:
[30:09] Wow.
Speaker 1:
[30:10] Blythe Terrell, executive editor here at Science Vs.
Speaker 14:
[30:16] Yeah. She tried it. It worked for her. Here she is again.
Speaker 2:
[30:20] I do notice that if I'm on socials or whatever, I'm like, none of this looks like fun. Like, it really, nothing is popping. And also, you know what the main thing is? Is that my phone does not look like a bag of jelly beans anymore. Like, it's really striking when you turn it back on, when you turn the color on, you're like, ooh, candy, candy store. And when you put it on grayscale, you're like, ow, it looks like I'm reading a newspaper.
Speaker 14:
[30:45] And Wendy, this is one of the things that, you know, I still have my phone on grayscale most of the time. I think it does help me too, which it kind of, it did make me think of a more sort of philosophical question about all this that I put to Lea. Is it a little sad that like we need to like put our worlds in black and white on our phones to get us to scroll less?
Speaker 16:
[31:07] I think of course, somehow it can be sad, but on the other hand, it can be so much more beautiful to realize all the colors in your real life. And I think we are so concentrated on the life that we see in our phones. Let's say our YouTube friends and everyone we are following. Like, of course, they have a beautiful life and the perfect flats, amazing holidays, great outfits. But what about your own life? What about your holiday, your friends, your dog? Yeah. The beautiful nature you're surrounded by. So I think if it helps us to realize, okay, we have that too, and we see all the colors in our life, we don't need color on our phone.
Speaker 1:
[31:55] Do you know, Meryl, I wonder if I had such a humdrum reaction to, okay, it's just my phone on grayscale, because the other day, I saw the most beautiful rainbow. It went over my house. I ran to one window, I saw the rainbow and then I ran to the other side. It's not a big house, but the other side and the rainbow was coming over my house. And so to put my phone on grayscale, not a big deal. Not a big deal.
Speaker 14:
[32:27] You already have all the colors of your life.
Speaker 5:
[32:30] That's right.
Speaker 1:
[32:32] But I'm sure that'll fade away. And then I'll just want to look at the cotton candy of my phone soon. So, okay, so I think my last question is, once people scroll less, do they actually feel better? Do they appreciate the rainbow in their life more?
Speaker 14:
[32:50] Well, the answer to this was sort of surprising. So there were a couple big trials that have found people's mental health gets a little better when they use their phones less. So like one study got hundreds of people and had some of them use their phones for an hour less every day. And it worked to like improve life satisfaction. But a lot of studies have been done on this. And some of them haven't found any benefit at all. Some have found like negative effects. And one review that I found that looked at three other reviews about like whether or not these interventions that reduce screen time affect well-being. They said that that was, quote, questionable.
Speaker 1:
[33:33] What?
Speaker 14:
[33:34] Yeah.
Speaker 1:
[33:35] What do you make of that? Of all this mix?
Speaker 14:
[33:38] Yeah, I think maybe for some people, they really don't need to be reducing their screen time to feel better. And maybe, you know, we shouldn't be beating ourselves up if we're having a hard time with this, because there's no guarantee that cutting down on screen time is going to like turn your life around. But on the other hand, like for me, I think it does help.
Speaker 1:
[33:57] Yeah. Yeah. And for all of our listeners who are saying that they really struggle with this and everyone online who's really been responding to the news of that court case that came down last week, saying, you know, yeah, this is something that's maybe not the cause of all the sadness in my life, but I don't feel good after I kind of get sucked into my phone for a few hours.
Speaker 14:
[34:23] Yeah. But if this is a problem for you and you want to try changing something, Jaejeung said that the first thing that you got to do.
Speaker 3:
[34:32] You need to press the button and that starting point is really hard.
Speaker 14:
[34:38] Yeah, I noticed that too. Like when I first started researching for this episode, there was something in me that was just like, I don't want to do any of this. Like I just want to keep using my phone.
Speaker 3:
[34:49] Exactly. I think that's the hardest point.
Speaker 1:
[34:52] Wait, what does he mean, you need to press the button?
Speaker 14:
[34:55] I mean, for me, like when I started doing this research, I just like, I just felt like nothing was really going to work. I read about gray scale and the first time I heard of it, I was just like, that sounds kind of like dumb. I'm not going to do that.
Speaker 1:
[35:07] Yeah, that's kind of where I'm at.
Speaker 14:
[35:09] But I think I was just resistant to doing anything. Really? Like I was just feeling kind of lazy. And so Jaejeung is basically like, just starting is often the hardest part of this. And for him, this means just like putting his phone in a different room sometimes if he's working or going to bed. And then he has this one thing he does for when he's already in a scrolling session.
Speaker 3:
[35:34] I just physically, I talk to myself, hey, stop using and just start work or just do it.
Speaker 14:
[35:43] And then you're more likely to actually just like close your phone if you just tell yourself, hey, stop.
Speaker 3:
[35:49] Yes.
Speaker 14:
[35:50] Interesting.
Speaker 3:
[35:51] Physically speaking, it works for me, but I'm not sure if it works for others, but it does for me.
Speaker 1:
[35:56] I do find that when I am scrolling and don't want to be anymore, really questioning whether I'm enjoying any of the content I've just seen does help. So as an example, so I was on a good run because you can be on a good run with social media where you're getting video after video that's actually quite delightful. And then I stopped it when I saw this video of kids, of plucky little kids wearing mustaches and saying, I love wearing a mustache. And I was like, what the f*** am I doing with my life?
Speaker 14:
[36:40] That was your dark moment. I thought it was going to be way worse than that.
Speaker 5:
[36:43] That was enough.
Speaker 1:
[36:45] That was enough.
Speaker 14:
[36:47] Kids wearing mustaches.
Speaker 4:
[36:48] Phone in the bin.
Speaker 14:
[36:49] That was your wake up call.
Speaker 2:
[36:52] Exactly.
Speaker 1:
[36:54] That was it. Thanks, Meryl.
Speaker 14:
[36:55] Thanks, Wendy.
Speaker 1:
[36:56] That's Science Vs. And if you try any of the stuff that we've talked about on this episode, you put your phone in greyscale, you download an app that has a little nudge, you watch a dumb video that you despise and then you throw the phone in the bin. Please let us know on Instagram. We are at science underscore Vs. I'm on TikTok at WendyZuk and we love to hear from you. Meryl, how many citations are in this week's episode? Okay.
Speaker 14:
[37:29] We have 44 citations.
Speaker 1:
[37:31] Great.
Speaker 14:
[37:31] Which if you want to see those, you can go to the show notes and follow the links to the transcripts.
Speaker 1:
[37:43] This episode was produced by Meryl Horne, with help from me, Wendy Zukerman, Rose Rimler, Michelle Dang, and Aketi Foster-Keys. I'm the executive producer. We're edited by Blythe Terrell, fact-checking by Erica Akiko-Howard, mix and sound design by Bobby Lord, music written by Bobby Lord, Bumi Hidaka, So Wylie, Emma Munger, and Peter Leonard. Thank you so much to all of the researchers that we spoke to, including Dr. Kai Lukoff, Haiyan Seng Cho, Dr. Alex Holte, Dr. Jan Ole Rixen, Dr. Jay Olson, and Dr. Noah Castello. A big thanks to Joseph Lavelle Wilson and the Zukerman family. Science Vs. is a Spotify Studio's original. Listen to us for free on Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts. Just follow us and tap the bell if you want to get notifications when new episodes come out. I'm Wendy Zukerman, back to you next week.
Speaker 11:
[38:44] The right window treatments change everything, your sleep, your privacy, the way every room looks and feels. At blinds.com, we've spent 30 years making it surprisingly simple to get exactly what your home needs. We've covered over 25 million windows and have 50,000 five-star reviews to prove we deliver. Whether you DIY it or want a pro to handle everything from measure to install, we have you covered. Real design professionals, free samples, zero pressure. Right now, get up to 45% off site-wide, plus get a free professional measure at blinds.com. Rules and restrictions apply.